Backups: External Drive, Cloud or NAS?
By Ren Lipu, freelance IT specialist in France
· Updated · 5 min read
A stolen laptop, a failed disk, a phone dropped in water or a ransomware attack, and years of photos or business documents can vanish in seconds. Backups are rarely a priority until something goes wrong, and then they become urgent when it is too late. This guide compares the three main options, external drive, cloud and NAS, and suggests a simple setup for a family as well as for a small business.
The 3-2-1 rule, the basis of any backup
The 3-2-1 rule is the most widely used benchmark, for individuals and businesses alike. It rests on a simple idea: no single copy is infallible, so you spread copies across different media and places.
It is not complicated to set up. For example: files on the computer, a copy on an external drive or NAS at home, and a copy in a cloud service.
- 3 copies of your data, including the original
- On 2 different types of media (computer and drive, NAS and cloud…)
- With 1 copy outside your home or office
- Ideally, one copy that is disconnected or protected from changes
Sync is not backup
Many people feel protected because their files are “in the cloud”. But a sync service mirrors changes everywhere: if a file is deleted, edited by mistake or encrypted by ransomware, the change also reaches the online copy.
A real backup keeps earlier versions so you can roll back. Some cloud services keep version history and a recycle bin for a limited time; check these settings instead of assuming them.
External hard drive
This is the simplest and cheapest way to start. Windows includes built-in backup tools, and Time Machine on a Mac automatically backs up the whole system whenever the drive is connected.
Its main weakness is human: you have to remember to plug it in. And if it stays permanently next to the computer, it shares the same risks (theft, water damage, fire, ransomware encrypting everything connected).
- Pros: inexpensive, fast, no subscription
- Cons: depends on your discipline
- Risks: drops, failure, same location as the computer
- Tip: unplug after each backup and rotate two drives
Cloud storage
Online services (iCloud, Google Drive or Google Photos, OneDrive, or dedicated backup services) are automatic and stored away from your home: they naturally cover the “1” in the 3-2-1 rule.
In return, you need a subscription once the free space is used up, a decent connection for the first upload, and good account security. Turn on two-factor authentication: a hijacked account can be wiped as quickly as a drive. Businesses should also check where data is hosted and whether the terms fit GDPR requirements.
NAS (network storage)
A NAS is a small storage server connected to your router. It centralises files for the whole household or office, automatically backs up several computers and phones, and can itself send a copy to the cloud.
Beware of a common misconception: a NAS with two mirrored disks (RAID) protects against one disk failing, but it is not a backup. A deletion, a mistake or ransomware hits both disks at once. A NAS should be one link in the chain, not the whole chain, and it needs some setup and regular updates.
Two simple setups that work
For a family, the goal is mostly to protect photos and important papers with no daily effort. A small business also needs to think about continuity: how long could you work without your client files, quotes or accounts?
- Family: automatic phone backup to the cloud
- Family: an external drive for the computer, plugged in monthly
- Family: important papers scanned into a backed-up folder
- Business: a NAS backing up every workstation daily
- Business: an encrypted NAS copy to the cloud, with version history
- Business: a disconnected drive, refreshed regularly and stored elsewhere
Test your restores, the forgotten step
A backup is only worth something if you can get your files back. Many people discover on the day of a failure that their backup stopped months ago, or never included the right folder.
A few times a year, restore a random file or folder and check that it opens properly. Also check the date of the last successful backup: most software shows it clearly.
Setting up your backups with some help
Ren Lipu helps households and small businesses in Marseille, Aix-en-Provence and Chambéry choose and install a backup solution: external drive, cloud, NAS, and NAS-to-cloud backup. Setup and follow-up can also be done remotely anywhere in France.
The first consultation is free: it helps list what needs protecting and choose a solution that fits your needs. Network and NAS installations are quoted case by case.
Frequently asked questions
- My photos are in iCloud or Google Photos. Is that enough?
- It is a good first layer, but it is often sync rather than backup. An extra copy on a drive or NAS protects you against accidental deletion or account problems.
- How often should I back up?
- The easiest approach is to make backups automatic. Otherwise, match the frequency to what you could accept losing: daily for a business, weekly or monthly for a family.
- Is a NAS useful for a household?
- Yes if several people share lots of photos and videos, or if you want to centralise backups. For a single computer, an external drive plus the cloud is often enough.
- How long does an external hard drive last?
- No lifespan is guaranteed: a drive can fail at any time. That is exactly why it should never be your only copy.
Read next
- Weak Wi-Fi at Home: Repeater, Mesh or Powerline?Wi-Fi that won’t get through your walls? Router placement, 2.4 vs 5 GHz, repeater, Mesh, powerline or Ethernet: how to pick the right fix for your home.
- How Much Does a Website Cost in 2026?What does a website cost for a shop, tradesperson or restaurant? Typical ranges, yearly fees and how to compare quotes with confidence.
- Google Business Profile: A Guide for Local FirmsSet up and optimise your Google Business Profile: categories, photos, hours, reviews and consistent contact details to get found by local customers.